- Nahren Recipe Club
- Posts
- 3 Minute, $2.00 Orange Creamsicle Smoothie
3 Minute, $2.00 Orange Creamsicle Smoothie
This nostalgic smoothie tastes like childhood summer in a glass.

Hey there!
I’ve been testing different creamsicle combinations and this bright orange smoothie was amazing at only $2.00 a serving. Here’s how you can make it in 3 mins with just a blender…
The prices below come straight from Nahren, the grocery app that shows the prices of groceries at every store in your area side by side. Guarantee your list is the cheapest it can be in seconds today. Compare prices with Nahren →
Ingredients (Serves 1, about $2.00 each)
Ingredient | Amount | Est. Cost* |
|---|---|---|
2 small | $1.65 | |
3 tsp | $0.05 | |
1/4 tsp | $0.05 | |
1/2 cup | $0.25 | |
Ice cubes | 1/2 cup | $0.00 |
Prices pulled with Nahren on August 02 for Athens, GA.
Method
Prep the cuties. Peel both baby cuties completely and break into segments, removing any visible seeds.
Add to blender. Place cuties segments, honey, vanilla extract, whole milk, and ice cubes into your blender.
Blend until smooth. Blend on high speed for 45-60 seconds until completely smooth and frothy. I use the Ninja Bullet which works perfectly for single-serving smoothies.
Serve immediately. Pour into a tall glass and enjoy right away while cold and creamy.
Tips
Fresh is key – Use juicy, ripe cuties for the best flavor. Give them a gentle squeeze at the store to test for ripeness!
Adjust sweetness – Start with 2 tsp honey and add more to taste. Some cuties are naturally sweeter than others.
Make it richer – Substitute half-and-half for the whole milk to create an even more indulgent creamsicle experience.